Discretionary trading.

We have had this discussion on several occasions but I feel I must raise it yet again.

Without doubt Pascal and Billy's daily comments have a strong influence on our trading because, naturally they are the originators of the system we are closely following and your comments will affect us psychologically.

Today, Pascal advised to trade lightly the Strong Short signal on GDX and also he will keep an eye on the GDX MF for better entry. Obviously, these are both discretionary decisions and IMHO will probably influence many of us here.

My question to Pascal and Billy - can you quantify that your discretionary trades add value to a completely mechanical approach too the Robots which you have shown to work well over the medium term ?

Thanks in advance for all you do but this is a very big question for us all. Thanks in advance

Trev.